Some places in the world whisper through empty shores, slow mornings, salt-stained skin, and the rare privilege of space. In a world chasing overwater villas and viral destinations, there are hidden gem islands that remain quietly untouched, not because they lack beauty, but because they refuse to perform. These places offer something far rarer than indulgence: presence, perspective, and a deeper rhythm of living. This is a hidden luxury. And these are islands where you don’t just stay, you arrive.
Below is a guide to 12 of the world’s most captivating hidden gem islands, chosen for their atmosphere, authenticity, and ability to offer a true reset.
Why Seek Out Hidden Gem Islands?
From the misty cliffs of the North Atlantic to the bioluminescent bays of the Caribbean, discovering hidden gem islands provides:
🏝️ Escape from overcrowded tourist trails and commercial resorts
🌅 Authentic cultural immersion and slower-paced living
🌌 Unspoiled natural beauty, from dark sky sanctuaries to ancient forests
🛶 Unique, locally-owned accommodations that connect you to the community
🧘 A profound sense of peace and personal rediscovery
12 Best Hidden Gem Islands to Visit
1. Isla Holbox, Mexico
Holbox exists between land and sea, literally. With no paved roads and golf carts as the main transport, this hidden gem island offers flamingo-dotted lagoons by day and bioluminescent waters by night, reminding you that magic is real.
🏨 Where to Stay
Villas Caracol
Beachfront bungalows with a laid-back, bohemian vibe, steps from the sand. Villas Caracol offers rustic charm and direct ocean access.
Mystique Holbox by Royalton
A stylish, adults-only retreat offering refined comfort and sophisticated design on a pristine beach. Mystique Holbox by Royalton is perfect for a serene escape.
Las Nubes De Holbox
A boutique eco-hotel featuring colorful, artistically designed rooms and a beachfront infinity pool. Las Nubes De Holbox blends comfort with sustainability and creative design.
✨ Top Experiences
Magic Night of Stargazing and Bioluminescence: A mesmerizing tour to witness the natural glow of bioluminescent plankton under a canopy of stars, a true highlight of this hidden gem island.
Whale Shark and Snorkeling Adventure
An unforgettable opportunity to swim alongside gentle whale sharks in their natural habitat, combined with snorkeling in pristine Caribbean waters. Whale Shark and Snorkeling Adventure.
2. Isle of Eigg, Scotland
Community-owned, wind-powered, and radically intentional, this small Scottish hidden gem island offers dramatic cliffs, cold waters, and a sense of ethical belonging that feels rare in travel today.
🏨 Where to Stay
Lageorna
A welcoming guesthouse with stunning views, warm hospitality, and home-cooked meals. Lageorna is the heart of Eigg’s community spirit.
Glebe Barn Hostel
A cozy, eco-friendly hostel offering simple comfort and a welcoming community atmosphere. Glebe Barn Hostel is ideal for budget-conscious travelers seeking authenticity.
✨ Top Experiences
Eigg Adventures: Guided hikes, wildlife watching, and sea kayaking tours that reveal the raw beauty and rich history of this community-owned hidden gem island.
3. Panarea, Italy
Panarea is understated Italian elegance, volcanic, minimalist, and unbothered by trends. Smaller and quieter than its Aeolian siblings, this hidden gem island attracts those who understand that luxury doesn’t need explanation.
🏨 Where to Stay
Hotel La Piazza
A charming, family-run hotel in the heart of the village, offering simple comfort and a genuine Panarea experience. Hotel La Piazza is an authentic base for exploring.
Hotel Ristorante O Palmo
A traditional Italian hotel and restaurant with authentic charm and delicious local cuisine. Hotel Ristorante O Palmo offers genuine Aeolian hospitality.
✨ Top Experiences
Panarea and Stromboli Boat Excursion: A breathtaking day trip to witness the volcanic might of Stromboli and the secluded coves around this stunning hidden gem island.
4. Koh Phayam, Thailand
Koh Phayam offers a version of Thailand that exists beyond itineraries, where simplicity becomes the ultimate luxury. With no cars and a slow, friendly rhythm, it’s a perfect hidden gem island to disconnect.
🏨 Where to Stay
Phayamas Private Beach Resort
An intimate, adults-only resort right on a long, sandy beach. Phayamas Private Beach Resort offers privacy, tranquility, and direct access to the Andaman Sea.
Phuree Hut
Simple, rustic beachfront bungalows with a relaxed island vibe. Phuree Hut provides an authentic back-to-basics beach experience.
Flower Power Farm Village & Restaurant
An eco-friendly farm stay with organic gardens and farm-to-table dining. Flower Power Farm Village offers a unique sustainable island experience.
5. Île de Houat, France
Just off the coast of Brittany, Houat feels almost deliberately overlooked. Fishermen shape the pace of life on this hidden gem island. Houses cluster quietly. Beaches remain untouched. Tourism exists, but never dominates.
🏨 Where to Stay
L’Ezenn
A simple, welcoming hotel and crêperie right by the port, embodying the unpretentious spirit of the island. L’Ezenn is a perfect base for exploring this French hidden gem island.
La Boîte à Poisson
A charming guesthouse with stunning sea views and warm Breton hospitality. La Boîte à Poisson offers cozy comfort and fresh seafood.
6. Fogo Island, Canada
Remote, wind-swept, and emotionally arresting, Fogo Island sits at the edge of the North Atlantic. The landscape is raw, and the culture is deeply rooted in storytelling and resilience. Luxury here is intellectual and architectural.
🏨 Where to Stay
Fogo Island Inn
An architectural marvel and social enterprise, offering breathtaking views, profound comfort, and a deep connection to community. Fogo Island Inn redefines the hidden gem island experience.
Escape By The Sea
A cozy oceanfront retreat offering comfortable accommodation with spectacular Atlantic views. Escape By The Sea provides a more accessible Fogo Island experience.
7. Sark, Channel Islands
Sark abolished cars decades ago and artificial streetlights more recently. What remains is silence, cliff-lined drama, and some of the darkest night skies in Europe. This hidden gem island is a step back in time.
🏨 Where to Stay
Stocks Hotel
Sark’s premier hotel, set in beautiful gardens with an award-winning restaurant. Stocks Hotel offers elegant comfort in the heart of this car-free hidden gem island.
Clos de Menage Country House
A charming country house offering peaceful accommodation in traditional style. Clos de Menage Country House provides a quieter alternative on Sark.
8. Kadavu, Fiji
Kadavu is Fiji without performance. Far from resort-heavy islands, it offers volcanic hills, rainforest interiors, and access to the Great Astrolabe Reef. Life here is guided by community and respect for nature, a true hidden gem island.
🏨 Where to Stay
Papageno Resort & Dive
An eco-friendly resort focused on diving and cultural immersion. Papageno Resort & Dive offers access to world-class reefs and genuine Fijian hospitality on this hidden gem island.
Tiliva Resort
A comfortable beachfront resort offering excellent diving and snorkeling opportunities. Tiliva Resort provides a welcoming base for exploring Kadavu’s underwater wonders.
9. Yakushima, Japan
Yakushima feels ancient, because it is. Home to thousand-year-old cedar trees and mist-covered forests, this Japanese hidden gem island inspired animation and myth. It’s a place where rain is constant and welcomed.
🏨 Where to Stay
Cottage Morinokokage
A cozy, traditional wooden cottage nestled in the forest, perfect for hikers and nature lovers. Cottage Morinokokage offers an authentic retreat on this mystical hidden gem island.
Samana Hotel Yakushima
A comfortable, modern hotel offering easy access to Yakushima’s mystical forests and hot springs. Samana Hotel Yakushima provides a welcoming base for exploring this ancient island.
10. Astypalea, Greece
Astypalea sits quietly between the Cyclades and the Dodecanese. Whitewashed villages rise like sculpture. The sea stays clear and uncrowded. This hidden gem island offers Greek island charm without the crowds.
🏨 Where to Stay
Gerani Studios
Simple, clean, and excellent value studios with a fantastic view of the Chora. Gerani Studios is a perfect base for exploring this beautiful hidden gem island.
Popi Studios
Well-appointed studios with sea views and traditional Greek hospitality. Popi Studios offers comfort and convenience for exploring Astypalea.
✨ Top Experiences
Astypalaia Daily Cruise: Explore the secluded beaches, crystal-clear waters, and dramatic rock formations around this stunning hidden gem island by boat.
11. Sumba, Indonesia
Sumba is not Bali’s quieter cousin. It’s something entirely its own. Wild, spiritually grounded, and culturally intact, this hidden gem island offers a powerful reminder that modernity isn’t the only path forward.
🏨 Where to Stay
Maringi Sumba
A boutique hotel committed to sustainability and cultural preservation. Maringi Sumba offers beautiful design and a deep connection to the land and people of this remarkable hidden gem island.
Sumba Nautil Resort
A beachfront resort with traditional architecture and modern amenities. Sumba Nautil Resort combines comfort with cultural authenticity.
12. Flores Island, Portugal
Flores feels like a living painting, green cliffs, volcanic pools, waterfalls falling without ceremony. Part of the Azores yet often overlooked, this hidden gem island rewards travelers who value solitude and wild beauty.
🏨 Where to Stay
Aldeia da Cuada
A restored 18th-century village turned into unique stone cottages. Aldeia da Cuada offers incredible character, privacy, and a deep sense of place on this Azorean hidden gem island.
Villas do Mar
Modern seaside villas with spectacular ocean views and all comforts. Villas do Mar provides contemporary luxury in a stunning natural setting.
✨ Top Experiences
Complete Tour of Flores Island: A comprehensive guided tour to discover the waterfalls, volcanic lakes, and dramatic coastal scenery of this breathtaking hidden gem island.
Practical Tips for Visiting Hidden Gem Islands
Plan for slower travel: Reaching these hidden gem islands often involves multiple forms of transport. Build in buffer time and see the journey as part of the adventure.
Respect the community: You are a guest. Support local businesses, learn about customs, and travel with a light footprint.
Pack for self-sufficiency: Some islands have limited shopping. Bring essentials, including any specific medications, and a good reusable water bottle.
Embrace the weather: These islands are beautiful because they’re wild. Pack layers and waterproof gear, and don’t let a little rain stop you.
Disconnect to reconnect: Internet can be limited or non-existent. View this as a feature, not a bug. It’s a chance to truly unwind.
FAQs About Hidden Gem Island Travel
Final Thoughts on Your Hidden Gem Island Journey
The quiet thread connecting these hidden gem islands is restraint. They resist mass tourism, performative luxury, and the pressure to scale. Instead, they offer depth over distraction, learning over leisure, and experiences that stay with you long after you return. Finding these hidden gem islands is about more than a vacation, it’s a return to a more intentional way of traveling and living.
In choosing these offbeat islands, you are not escaping life. You are remembering how to live it, fully present in places that still hold their mystery and soul.
Best Travel Tips
Book Your Flight
Find the cheapest flight by using Skyscanner. For over a decade I've found it to nearly always offer the best deals.
Book Your Accommodation
You can book your hotel or guesthouse with Agoda as it consistently has the best rates.
Always Use Travel Insurance
Travel insurance safeguards you against illness, injury, theft, and cancellations, providing peace of mind if anything goes wrong. My top pick for excellent service and value is SquareMouth (best for all age groups.)
Need Help Finding Activities for Your Trip?
- Economy to Mid-Range
- TripAdvisor
- Go With Guide Mid-Range to Luxury
- TRAFALGAR
Stay Connected While Traveling
Cheapest Way to Transfer Money
I’ve been using XE for all my international money transfers, and it’s been a game changer. The fees are super low, and I get the real exchange rate which saves a lot. The normal fee is usually just a couple dollars per transaction.
Ready to Book Your Trip?
Take a look at my resource page for top travel companies and tips. I’ve listed all my personal favorites that I've used over years of full-time travel, each best in class, so you can’t plan your trip wrong!
