Last updated on July 13th, 2025
From the historic charm of Victorian mansions to the laid-back luxury of oceanfront resorts, Key West is an island paradise where relaxation meets sophistication. Whether you seek panoramic ocean views, serene spa experiences, or world-class dining, these top-rated Key West hotels blend tropical hospitality with distinctive Florida Keys charm.
Here are the best hotels in Key West for an unforgettable stay in the Conch Republic.
Why Stay at Key West’s Best Hotels?
Key West’s finest hotels offer:
🏨 Private beach access with sunset views
🍽️ Fresh seafood dining and Duval Street nightlife
🚤 Luxury yacht charters and water sports
💆 Oceanfront spas with tropical treatments
🌆 Prime locations near Hemingway House and Mallory Square
Best Hotels in Key West
1. Ocean Key Resort & Spa
The iconic Ocean Key Resort & Spa offers the best sunset views in Key West from its prime Mallory Square location. My evening at Hot Tin Roof restaurant, watching performers while the sun dipped below the horizon, was pure magic. The resort’s private pier and zero-entry pool redefine tropical luxury.
- Area: Mallory Square
- Highlights: Sunset views, spa services, waterfront dining
- Perfect for: Couples and sunset enthusiasts
2. Sunset Key Cottages
Accessible only by private ferry, Sunset Key Cottages offers an exclusive island retreat just 500 yards from Key West. My two-bedroom cottage with a private plunge pool was the ultimate luxury, and breakfast delivered to my porch each morning was perfection.
- Area: Private Island
- Highlights: Private beach, personal concierge, luxury cottages
- Perfect for: Honeymooners & privacy seekers
3. Opal Key Resort & Marina
The newly renovated Opal Key Resort & Marina combines modern luxury with classic Key West charm. My balcony overlooking the marina was perfect for morning coffee, and the resort’s central location made exploring Duval Street effortless.
- Area: Historic Seaport
- Highlights: Deep-water marina, rooftop pool, walking distance to attractions
- Perfect for: Boaters and first-time visitors
4. The Capitana Key West
This boutique beachfront property, The Capitana Key West, offers an intimate escape with direct beach access. The private cabanas and beachside service made my days here unforgettable.
- Area: Smathers Beach
- Highlights: Private beach, oceanfront dining, luxury cabanas
- Perfect for: Beach lovers and romantic getaways
5. Marquesa Hotel
The historic Marquesa Hotel transports guests to Old Key West with its four Victorian houses surrounding a lush tropical garden. My afternoon by the cascading waterfall pool felt worlds away from bustling Duval Street just steps away.
- Area: Old Town
- Highlights: Historic charm, award-winning restaurant, tranquil gardens
- Perfect for: History buffs and architecture lovers
6. The Gardens Hotel
This tropical oasis in the heart of Old Town, The Gardens Hotel, features one of Key West’s most spectacular private gardens. My morning coffee surrounded by rare tropical plants was a serene start to each day.
- Area: Old Town
- Highlights: Botanical gardens, heated pool, historic mansion
- Perfect for: Nature lovers and relaxation seekers
7. Hyatt Vacation Club at Beach House, Key West
The Hyatt Vacation Club at Beach House offers spacious suites perfect for families, just steps from the southernmost beach in the continental U.S. The full kitchens and separate living areas provide all the comforts of home.
- Area: South Beach
- Highlights: Full kitchens, beachfront location, family-friendly
- Perfect for: Families and extended stays
8. Simonton Court Hotel Key West
Spread across four historic buildings, Simonton Court Hotel offers charming cottages and suites surrounding four pools. My private veranda overlooking the lush gardens was the perfect spot for evening cocktails.
- Area: Old Town
- Highlights: Historic cottages, multiple pools, tropical gardens
- Perfect for: Couples and small groups
9. La Mer Hotel & Dewey House
This boutique beachfront property, La Mer Hotel & Dewey House, combines historic charm with modern luxury. My oceanfront suite with a private balcony offered breathtaking sunrise views over the Atlantic.
- Area: Duval Street
- Highlights: Private beach access, historic architecture, oceanfront dining
- Perfect for: Romantic getaways and history lovers
10. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
The Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa offers contemporary luxury steps from Duval Street. The full-service spa and oceanfront pool deck provide the perfect balance of activity and relaxation.
- Area: Historic Seaport
- Highlights: Full-service spa, oceanfront dining, modern design
- Perfect for: Sophisticated travelers and spa enthusiasts
FAQs About The Best Hotels in Key West
Final Tips for Booking Key West Hotels
– Old Town hotels offer historic charm but can be noisy at night
– Beachfront properties often require reservations for chairs and cabanas
– Book sunset cruises and water sports in advance during peak season
– Check for Florida resident discounts if eligible
Whether you choose a historic inn or a modern beachfront resort, the best hotels in Key West promise an unforgettable tropical getaway filled with sunshine, relaxation, and island charm.
Best Travel Tips
Book Your Flight
Find the cheapest flight by using Skyscanner. For over a decade I've found it to nearly always offer the best deals.
Book Your Accommodation
You can book your hotel or guesthouse with Agoda as it consistently has the best rates.
Always Use Travel Insurance
Travel insurance safeguards you against illness, injury, theft, and cancellations, providing peace of mind if anything goes wrong. My top pick for excellent service and value is SafetyWing (best for all age groups.)
Need Help Finding Activities for Your Trip?
-
Economy to Mid-Range
- TripAdvisor
- Get Your Guide Mid-Range to Luxury
- TRAFALGAR
Stay Connected While Traveling
Cheapest Way to Transfer Money
I’ve been using XE for all my international money transfers, and it’s been a game changer. The fees are super low, and I get the real exchange rate which saves a lot. The normal fee is usually just a couple dollars per transaction.
Ready to Book Your Trip?
Take a look at my resource page for top travel companies and tips. I’ve listed all my personal favorites that I've used over years of full-time travel, each best in class, so you can’t plan your trip wrong!
